ENH-TMPL-004: Template Validation Framework - Implementation Summary

Overview

This document summarizes the implementation of the comprehensive template validation framework for RE-cue, as specified in enhancement ENH-TMPL-004.

Requirements Met

✅ Check for Required Variables

Status: Already implemented, enhanced with auto-fix integration

The validator checks for required placeholder variables in templates:

validator.validate_template(
    template_path,
    required_placeholders={'PROJECT_NAME', 'DATE', 'ENDPOINT_COUNT'}
)

✅ Validate Markdown Syntax

Status: Already implemented, enhanced with auto-fix

Validates:

Markdown heading structure
Code block balance
Link integrity
Overall markdown structure

✅ Report Missing Placeholders

Status: Already implemented

Reports detailed information about:

Missing required placeholders
Found placeholders
Validation errors and warnings

✅ Verify Template Completeness

Status: Already implemented, enhanced

Verifies:

Template structure is complete
All sections are present
Framework-specific patterns exist
Code blocks are properly formatted

✅ Auto-Fix Common Issues (NEW)

Status: Newly implemented ✨

Implemented auto-fix capabilities for:

Unbalanced Code Blocks
- Automatically adds missing closing ``` markers
- Prevents markdown rendering issues
Broken Markdown Links
- Removes empty link URLs: [text]() → text
- Preserves link text for readability
Missing Code Block Languages
- Adds appropriate language specifications
- Framework-aware (java, python, javascript, etc.)
- Improves syntax highlighting
Heading Hierarchy Issues
- Converts h1 to h2 for templates
- Ensures consistent template structure

Implementation Details

New Components

1. Auto-Fix Infrastructure

File: reverse-engineer-python/reverse_engineer/templates/template_validator.py

Added methods:

_auto_fix_template() - Main auto-fix orchestration
_fix_unbalanced_code_blocks() - Code block fixes
_fix_broken_links() - Link fixes
_fix_code_block_languages() - Language specification fixes
_fix_heading_hierarchy() - Heading level fixes
_get_default_language() - Framework-aware language detection

Enhanced ValidationResult dataclass:

Added fixes_applied field to track auto-fixes
Updated string representation to show fixes

2. Enhanced CLI

File: reverse-engineer-python/reverse_engineer/templates/template_validator.py

Added command-line options:

--auto-fix           # Enable automatic fixing
--template-dir PATH  # Specify custom template directory

3. Comprehensive Tests

File: reverse-engineer-python/tests/test_template_validator.py

Added test classes:

TestAutoFix - 7 tests for auto-fix functionality
TestValidationResultWithFixes - 2 tests for result formatting

Total tests increased: 21 → 30 tests

Test Coverage

All new functionality is fully tested:

✅ test_auto_fix_unbalanced_code_blocks
✅ test_auto_fix_broken_links
✅ test_auto_fix_code_block_languages
✅ test_auto_fix_heading_hierarchy
✅ test_auto_fix_multiple_issues
✅ test_no_auto_fix_when_disabled
✅ test_get_default_language
✅ test_result_with_fixes_str
✅ test_result_with_all_types

Documentation

1. Feature Documentation

File: docs/features/template-validation.md

Comprehensive documentation covering:

Overview of all features
Usage examples (CLI and API)
Validation rules and exit codes
CI/CD integration examples
Best practices
Extension guide

2. Quick Start Guide

File: docs/user-guides/template-validation-quick-start.md

User-friendly guide with:

Quick validation commands
Example output
Common issues and solutions
CI/CD integration examples
Best practices

Usage Examples

Command Line

# Basic validation
python3 -m reverse_engineer.templates.template_validator

# Auto-fix mode
python3 -m reverse_engineer.templates.template_validator --auto-fix

# Custom directory with auto-fix
python3 -m reverse_engineer.templates.template_validator \
    --template-dir /path/to/templates \
    --auto-fix

Programmatic API

from pathlib import Path
from reverse_engineer.templates.template_validator import TemplateValidator

# Validate with auto-fix
validator = TemplateValidator()
result = validator.validate_template(
    Path('templates/phase1-structure.md'),
    framework_id='java_spring',
    auto_fix=True
)

# Check results
if result.fixes_applied:
    print("Fixes applied:")
    for fix in result.fixes_applied:
        print(f"  - {fix}")

Validation Report Format

The enhanced validation report now shows:

🔧 Auto-fix mode enabled - fixing common issues...

======================================================================
Template Validation Report
======================================================================

COMMON:
----------------------------------------------------------------------
✅ phase1-structure.md
    🔧 Added 'text' language to code block at line 72
    🔧 Converted first heading from h1 to h2
✅ base.md
    🔧 Added missing code block closing marker

======================================================================
Summary: 2 templates validated
  Fixes Applied: 3
  Errors: 0
  Warnings: 0
  Status: ✅ All valid
======================================================================

Benefits Delivered

1. Improved Template Quality

Automatic correction of common formatting issues
Consistent heading hierarchy
Proper code block formatting
Clean markdown links

2. Developer Productivity

Saves time fixing repetitive issues
Reduces manual template cleanup
Prevents validation errors before commit

3. Better Documentation

Enhanced syntax highlighting with language specs
More readable markdown rendering
Professional template appearance

4. CI/CD Integration

Can be used in pre-commit hooks
GitHub Actions workflow ready
Exit codes for automation

5. Extensibility

Easy to add new fix rules
Framework-aware fixes
Customizable validation rules

Backward Compatibility

✅ Fully backward compatible

Auto-fix is opt-in via --auto-fix flag
Default behavior unchanged (validation only)
Existing API signatures preserved
All existing tests still pass (21/21)

Performance

Test execution time: ~15ms for 30 tests
Validation time: <1s for 26 templates
Auto-fix overhead: Minimal (~10-20ms per template)

Code Quality

Linting

All code passes ruff checks (except pre-existing complexity warnings)
Proper import ordering
Type hints used throughout

Testing

30 tests total (9 new tests added)
100% pass rate
Comprehensive coverage of auto-fix features

Documentation

Full API documentation
Usage examples
Integration guides
Best practices

Future Enhancements

Possible future improvements:

Additional Auto-Fixes
- Auto-add missing required placeholders with defaults
- Fix markdown table formatting
- Normalize whitespace
Configuration File
- Allow customization of validation rules
- Define required placeholders per template
- Framework-specific settings
IDE Integration
- VS Code extension integration
- Real-time validation feedback
- Quick fix suggestions
Enhanced Reporting
- HTML/JSON output formats
- Detailed fix descriptions
- Before/after diffs

Conclusion

The template validation framework enhancement (ENH-TMPL-004) has been successfully implemented with all required features:

✅ Check for required variables
✅ Validate markdown syntax
✅ Report missing placeholders
✅ Verify template completeness
✅ Auto-fix common issues

The implementation is well-tested, documented, and ready for production use. It delivers significant value by automating template quality maintenance while remaining fully backward compatible.

Files Changed

Core Implementation

reverse-engineer-python/reverse_engineer/templates/template_validator.py (enhanced)
reverse-engineer-python/tests/test_template_validator.py (enhanced)

Documentation

docs/features/template-validation.md (new)
docs/user-guides/template-validation-quick-start.md (new)
docs/releases/ENH-TMPL-004-implementation-summary.md (this file)

Test Results

Before: 21 tests passing
After: 30 tests passing
New tests: 9
All template-related tests: 113 passing

Implementation Date: December 22, 2025
Enhancement ID: ENH-TMPL-004
Category: Template System
Priority: Medium
Impact: Medium - Improves template quality
Effort: Medium (2-3 days) ✅ Completed

Feedback

Was this page helpful?

Glad to hear it! Please tell us how we can improve.

Sorry to hear that. Please tell us how we can improve.